Dear Authors
We have received the final reviews of your manuscript, which are overall positive.
Before being finally accepted for publication, I recommend considering and fixing the following aspects.
1) Please check and include in the final manuscript the additional recommendations of Reviewer #2
2) From my side, I noticed that, according to the section "Code Availability" of the MS, "the code CASP is available under license at https://lunitek.it/seismic/seismic-software/casp/" (line 624).
- At the mentioned website, I cannot find any details about the license under which the software is released. Please provide in the MS the details of the licence associated with the software, double-check and clearly state that such a licence does not imply any restrictions on the derived data (i.e., your catalogue).
- At line 67 (and not at line 43, where it is mentioned first), the CASP code is cited as Scafidi et al. (2019). Please clarify the relationship between this paper and the code mentioned in the section "Code availability".
- Please, provide the citations for the NNL and H71 codes also in the section "Code Availability".
Please also note that the Section "Code availability" must be placed after "Data Availability" and "Conclusions" (see https://www.earth-system-science-data.net/submission.html)
3) Please, include in the Abstract the full citation and DOI of your dataset, as per ESSD requirements (see https://www.earth-system-science-data.net/submission.html).

Best regards

Andrea Rovida
Topic Editor