Review of “Remote sensing measurements during PaCE 2022 campaign”

General comment: This study presents cloud remote sensing measurements and derived micro- and macrophysically properties from the PaCE 2022 campaign at the Kenttärova site in Finland. The manuscript is well-structured and clearly written and the dataset and software tools are available via open access.

These measurements provide a valuable contribution to the long-term atmospheric observation efforts within ACTRIS and the dataset is relevant for model evaluation and satellite validation efforts. The methodological implementation of the data collection, including multiple remote sensing instruments and the use of CloudnetPy processing and quality checks, ensures that the dataset is comprehensive and of high scientific value.

I recommend the manuscript for publication after minor comments have been addressed.

Minor comments:

Overall, I think, the presentation of the data set could benefit from validation and comparison to other measurements, e.g., collected during previous campaigns. This could help the user, for example, to assess the liquid water path retrieved by the cloud radar, as the standard Cloudnet instrumentation for this quantity is a microwave radiometer.

Also, an illustration of the VOODOO results would be helpful. The issue of missing liquid layers due to lidar attenuation is well known and VOODOO provides a valuable approach for the situations. Due to its still experimental stage, it would be good, to show and discuss the results of this method, for users inexperienced with VOODOO.

Specific comments:

Line 67: Change the sentence “...up to a height of 15 km height” to “...up to a height of 15 km” to avoid repetition.

Line 73: “attenuated backscatter cofficient” should be corrected to “attenuated backscatter coefficient.”

Line 163: Add a comma bevor “and higher-level derived synergetic geophysical products.”

Line 182: Change “according the FAIR principles” to “according to the FAIR principles.”