the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Seasonal evolution of a warm alpine snowpack: a multi-instrument dataset of snow microstructure at Col de Porte, French Alps
Abstract. Long-term snow observation sites provide valuable datasets for understanding snowpack evolution and evaluating snow models. Recent observation campaigns have progressively enriched these monitoring programs with high-resolution measurements of snow microstructure, particularly using the SnowMicroPen. Here, we present a two-winter dataset of snow and atmospheric observations collected at Col de Porte (French Alps, 1325 m), a warm alpine environment, during the winters 2021–2022 and
2022–2023. The dataset extends the standard observation program with weekly vertical profiles of snow density, specific surface area (SSA), structural anisotropy, and penetration resistance obtained from the SnowMicroPen, X-ray tomography, density cutters, and two optical reflectance instruments (DUFISSS and HISSGraS). Tomography measurements combined fast acquisitions (42 μm) and high-resolution acquisitions (10 μm). The study (i) provides a comprehensive dataset of snow microstructural properties together with atmospheric forcing for snow model evaluation under warm snow conditions, characterized by frequent wet snow and melt-freeze crusts, and (ii) assesses the strengths and limitations of the different measurement techniques, including the feasibility of seasonal snowpack monitoring by X-ray tomography, the use of the SnowMicroPen under warm snow conditions, and the agreement between the two optical reflectance instruments. The paper describes the meteorological and snowpack conditions during the two winters, presents multi-instrument vertical profiles of snow density and SSA, and reports the characteristic ranges of density, SSA, and structural anisotropy for the different snow types encountered at Col de
Porte. The dataset is available at https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.33426472 (Calonne et al., 2026).
- Preprint
(16304 KB) - Metadata XML
- BibTeX
- EndNote
Status: final response (author comments only)
-
RC1: 'Comment on essd-2026-718', Anonymous Referee #1, 23 Oct 2026
The comment was uploaded in the form of a supplement: https://essd.copernicus.org/preprints/essd-2026-718/essd-2026-718-RC1-supplement.pdfCitation: https://doi.org/
10.5194/essd-2026-718-RC1 -
RC2: 'Comment on essd-2026-718', Anonymous Referee #2, 15 Nov 2026
Review of “Seasonal evolution of a warm alpine snowpack: a multi-instrument dataset of snow microstructure at Col de Porte, French Alps” by Calonne et al., submitted to Earth System Science Data
This well-written and clearly structured data description manuscript details the seasonal evolution of the snowpack at the Col de Porte meteorological observatory in the French Alps during two contrasting winter seasons. The observations combine a range of instruments to measure detailed snow parameters such as specific surface area (SSA) and density, and the manuscript provides a concise intercomparison that establishes the consistency of the methods while highlighting the limitations of each. The data are already published in a clear and accessible form, and the data description given in the paper is thorough. The accompanying meteorological dataset is likewise already published, has recently been updated, and is distributed as user-friendly NetCDF files with good metadata, which further increases the usefulness of the snow dataset.
Of particular interest is the demonstrated feasibility of repeated, standardised sampling and measurement for computed tomography analysis, for which the practical and computational challenges are described well and set against other, more standard methods without going into excessive detail. The contrast between the two winter seasons is especially valuable for model evaluation: one season is representative of the reference period, while the other is an exceptionally low-snow year showing processes such as rain-on-snow events and multiple melt layers within a single snowpack.
I therefore recommend publication after minor revisions. The comments below are offered to strengthen an already strong manuscript.
General comments
- Liquid water content. The dataset is particularly valuable for the study of melt and warm-period snow processes, for which the distribution of liquid water is an open research question. At present, liquid water is reported only as a binary presence/absence flag, and the manuscript itself notes that this information is approximate, being inferred from observer comments or from temperature profiles that were not always recorded simultaneously (L. 457–460). Information on the vertical distribution of liquid water within the snowpack, even semi-quantitative, would considerably increase the value of the dataset. If such measurements are not available, I would ask the authors to state this limitation explicitly where the dataset is presented as a benchmark for snow model evaluation under warm conditions (L. 528–530).
- Snow temperature. Temperature profiles are referred to at several points (e.g. L. 372, Fig. 18) but are not presented consistently alongside the other snow properties. Please clarify which temperature measurements are part of the published dataset (or are they part of meteorological dataset?) and consider showing them systematically rather than for a single date (e.g. in Fig. 12-15).
- Snow-type characterisation. This dataset can contribute to the classification and generalisation of grain types in terms of their properties (density and SSA). I therefore suggest an SSA–density scatter plot with the different grain types grouped, potentially shown as box plots within the density–SSA plane, in the spirit of Domine et al. (2007, their Fig. 2), to replace or extend Fig. 16.
- Instrument intercomparison. The statement that a quantitative comparison between instruments cannot be performed without further profile processing (L. 374) is acceptable for a data description paper. It would nevertheless be helpful for future users if the authors pointed explicitly to the dates and depth ranges where the disagreement between instruments is largest (L. 374–381), and if some quantitative indication of the agreement between methods were given for the profiles shown in Figs. 12–15. In the same context, it might be helpful if the method (dynamic time warping?) for profile matching was described in more detail in Sect. 4.3 (L. 486–490).
- The introduction is strongly Europe-centred; the long-term observatories listed in L. 33–35 could usefully be extended to international sites. Conversely, the final paragraph of the introduction (L. 52–56) contains a level of methodological detail that may be better placed in the corresponding sections.
Specific comments
- Data access. The dataset is distributed as a single container, which is very large because it includes the segmented_images.tar file; this file is presumably of interest to only a small number of users. I suggest offering the option to download all processed data files in one go, while keeping the .zarr files optional.
- 39: The benefits of “high-resolution” SMP measurements are highlighted here. Could you name some of them specifically and/or point the reader to the relevant literature?
- 2.1, L. 63–65: Please add the typical snow cover period (snow on the ground) for the site.
- Table 1: Please add the units and the uncertainties of the measurements and instrument methods, and consider adding a reference describing each instrument.
- 3: Consider indicating the time of day at which the profiles were taken, and marking the occurrence of new snow. It would also be worth noting in the text that only about four weeks of the campaign carry a complete set of measurements from all instruments.
- 136: I appreciate that the authors also report their failed attempts and trials, which is helpful for others planning similar campaigns.
- 163–165: Were the edges of the sample cropped for the LR scans? Please clarify how the dimensions of the final cropped images relate to the dimensions of the sample.
- 6: Is this correction site or snow type-specific, or would the authors expect it to be transferable to other sites and datasets acquired with the same scan settings?
- 208: Relying on a single operator for the visual snow-type classification is a sound choice, and the resulting consistency across the dataset is a clear strength.
- 215: The underestimation of SSA by the LR scans above about 40 m² kg⁻¹ presumably concerns mainly fresh snow; please state this explicitly.
- 231–232: Please explain why the polynomial fit used here differs from the one given in Gallet et al. (2009).
- 240–244: What surface area and what penetration depth does HISSGraS actually sample? The same information as given for DUFISSS would help the reader interpret the comparison in Sect. 4.1.
- 249–252: Were the HISSGraS measurements carried out on the same pit face as the other SSA measurements?
- Also, in all Figures, please plot the SSA measurements as a “staircase plot”, similar to the density information, to avoid the impression of a smooth profile through the interpolation.
- 271 and L. 276: Please state explicitly whether the published SMP density and SSA profiles are the median profiles derived from the five measurements, and whether the five individual profiles are also provided in the dataset.
- 7c and 9c: How is the basal water runoff measured? Please add a brief description of the instrument and the method.
- 7b and 9b: Consider adding the ground (soil) temperature to these panels.
- 12–15: Consider plotting the measured temperature profiles on a secondary axis, as is done for a single date in Fig. 18. To save space, you could avoid adding the density label below every x-axes.
- 16: Please mark the isotropic value A = 1 with a horizontal reference line in the structural anisotropy panel, so that preferentially horizontal and vertical structures can be distinguished at a glance.
- 17: What are the measurement uncertainties of the two instruments? Adding error bars to panels a) to c) would help the reader judge the significance of the reported bias. Also, please consider plotting as staircase plot.
Technical corrections
- 32: replace “be simulated” with “be retrieved”.
- 37: change to “evaluating numerical snow models”.
- 41: change “a two-year dataset” to “a dataset obtained during two winter seasons of …”.
- 55–56: replace “notably” with “specifically”, and please check the grammar of this sentence.
- 73: brackets are missing around the citations.
- 101–102: replace “and a few cm past them” with “parallel to the SMP line, with an offset of a few centimetres”.
- 153: please add a citation.
- 5: the same measurement is referred to both as “fast scan” and as “LR scan”. Please use either fast/slow or HR/LR consistently throughout the text and figures. Is there a reason for showing the LR scan as a 2D image and the HR scan in 3D?
- Table 2: please add the length of the scanned sample to the duration given for the HR scan, as is done for the LR scan.
- 217: please give the dimensions of the 100 cm³ cutter in the same compact form as those of the 250 cm³ cutter, i.e. 3 × 5.5 × 6 cm and 10 × 10 × 2.5 cm.
- 310: change “densities mostly comprised between 400 and 500 kg m⁻³” to “densities mostly between 400 and 500 kg m⁻³” or “mostly ranging from 400 to 500 kg m⁻³”.
- 323: for consistency with Sect. 3.1.1 (“Winter 2021–2022”), the heading should read “Winter 2022–2023” rather than “Winter season 2022–2023”. The same applies to the panel title of Fig. 10.
- 429: “Dedicated” should not be capitalised mid-sentence.
- 502–504: the set of derived properties (density, SSA, structural anisotropy) is listed twice in consecutive sentences; please condense.
Reference
Domine, F., Taillandier, A.-S., and Simpson, W. R.: A parameterization of the specific surface area of seasonal snow for field use and for models of snowpack evolution, J. Geophys. Res., 112, 2006JF000512, https://doi.org/10.1029/2006JF000512, 2007.
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/essd-2026-718-RC2
Data sets
Dataset of "Seasonal evolution of a warm alpine snowpack: a multi-instrument dataset of snow microstructure at Col de Porte, French Alps" Neige Calonne, Pascal Hagenmuller, Rémi Granger, Lisa Bouvet, Kévin Fourteau, Julien Brondex, François Tuzet, Yves Lejeune, Anne Dufour, Mathieu Fructus, Teruo Aoki, and Marie Dumont https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.33426472
Viewed
| HTML | XML | Total | BibTeX | EndNote | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 413 | 153 | 56 | 622 | 84 | 79 |
- HTML: 413
- PDF: 153
- XML: 56
- Total: 622
- BibTeX: 84
- EndNote: 79
Viewed (geographical distribution)
| Country | # | Views | % |
|---|
| Total: | 0 |
| HTML: | 0 |
| PDF: | 0 |
| XML: | 0 |
- 1