Preprints
https://doi.org/10.5194/essd-2026-905
https://doi.org/10.5194/essd-2026-905
20 Nov 2026
 | 20 Nov 2026
Status: this preprint is currently under review for the journal ESSD.

Auditing the Global Carbon Budget: exploring the 2024–2025 vintage shift

Mikkel Bennedsen, Eric Hillebrand, and Siem Jan Koopman

Abstract. The Global Carbon Budget (GCB), the community reference dataset for the carbon cycle, is reissued annually. The 2025 release introduces several adjustments to the published series that we compare with prior releases starting in 2017. On a common 1959–2016 sample, the mean of the GCB budget imbalance jumps from within ±0.17 GtC/yr of zero for every vintage 2017–2024 to +0.61 GtC/yr in 2025, the only vintage whose 95 % confidence interval for the imbalance mean excludes zero. The size of the imbalance changes much less: its mean absolute value rises from 0.61 to 0.76 GtC/yr. It is the mean, the quantity the budget identity constrains, that moves. We document and explore this shift in two ways. First, we conduct a model-free analysis, where we attribute the shift to a new adjustment that places the published land sink 0.40 GtC/yr below its ensemble mean (the average of the underlying models), a smaller adjustment in the ocean sink in the opposite direction, and a change in the composition of the bookkeeping ensemble. Second, we consider the dynamic statistical GCB model of Bennedsen et al. (2023), augmented with climate covariates. Its parameters are estimated for every GCB vintage 2017–2025. The coefficients of atmospheric concentrations in the sink equations shift in opposite directions on the 2025 issue, mirroring the model-free findings. A constant in the budget equation, statistically unnecessary in every vintage from 2017 to 2024, is required in 2025 and is estimated at −0.59 (0.06) GtC/yr. There is a persistent drifting imbalance across the entire sample in the budget equation. Each of the three adjustments is documented in the 2025 release and rests on evidence about the component it corrects. Their joint effect is a budget that closes over the last ten years and carries a mean imbalance of +0.61 GtC/yr over the full record. We argue that this cost to the full sample outweighs the gain on the last ten years.

Publisher's note: Copernicus Publications remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims made in the text, published maps, institutional affiliations, or any other geographical representation in this paper. While Copernicus Publications makes every effort to include appropriate place names, the final responsibility lies with the authors. Views expressed in the text are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the publisher.
Share
Mikkel Bennedsen, Eric Hillebrand, and Siem Jan Koopman

Status: open (until 27 Dec 2026)

Comment types: AC – author | RC – referee | CC – community | EC – editor | CEC – chief editor | : Report abuse
Mikkel Bennedsen, Eric Hillebrand, and Siem Jan Koopman

Model code and software

Replication code repository Mikkel Bennedsen et al. https://github.com/chisos9/gcb-audit-replication/releases/tag/v01

Mikkel Bennedsen, Eric Hillebrand, and Siem Jan Koopman
Metrics will be available soon.
Latest update: 20 Nov 2026
Download
Short summary
Every year, the Global Carbon Budget reports how much carbon dioxide human activities release and how much ends up in the atmosphere, on land, and in the ocean. These widely used accounts never balance exactly, but for years the gap averaged out to nearly zero. We built statistical checks that trace such gaps to their sources and find that revisions in the 2025 edition leave a gap that no longer averages away. Anyone combining numbers from different editions should take this into account.
Share
Altmetrics