the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Species- and region-specific growth curves, forest age (2020), and disturbance trends for French forests at 30 m resolution
Abstract. Spatially explicit biomass growth curves data that jointly resolve tree species, stand age and disturbance regime are scarce, particularly at fine spatial resolutions. We present five consistent data products for metropolitan French forests around 2020, derived from a 30 m dominant-species map, the 30 m FORMS-B satellite above-ground biomass (AGB) map and the Landsat-based European Forest Disturbance Atlas: (1) 290 AGB growth curves for 28 species categories across 11 large ecological regions; (2) a 30 m forest age map for 2020 covering 17.01 Mha of forests, obtained by inverting these curves against the AGB map; (3) 3,752 harvest and natural disturbance rates and patch sizes, with their 1999–2024 trends; (4) 3,752 event-based disturbance severities (AGB loss per disturbed hectare); and (5) 1,874 rotation periods from National Forest Inventory (NFI) plot samples remeasurements. Products 3–5 cover 28 species categories across 86 small ecological regions. These cover the species×region combinations present in French forests, not the full combinatorial grid. Not all 28 species categories occur in every ecological region; the totals reflect strata with forest area only. All products include uncertainties and gap-filling flags. Growth curves match National Forest Inventory-derived curves for early growth (+12±15 %, 95 % CI) but give a higher asymptotic biomass (+22±18 %) and a later half-saturation year (+33±23 %), partly reflecting differences in the representation of age extremes, as NFI measurements exclude trees <7.5 cm in diameter and we aggregate stands >60 years into a single age class. The age map matches the NFI nationally aggregated age distribution (median offset −2 [−20 to +42] yr). The 2020 harvested area (44±6 kha) and the resulting AGB loss (2.5±0.3 MtC.yr−1) are of the same order as independent clear-cut estimates (62 kha from the NFI; ~3 MtC.yr−1 from satellite-mapped clear-cuts over 2018–2024). The Landsat disturbance product captures only stand-replacing and high severity events and underestimate selective logging and diffuse mortality. These products can be combined directly to model forest carbon dynamics at species and regional resolution. All data are openly available at https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23499335 (Pellissier-Tanon et al., 2026).
- Preprint
(3545 KB) - Metadata XML
-
Supplement
(4426 KB) - BibTeX
- EndNote
Status: open (until 09 Dec 2026)
- RC1: 'Comment on essd-2026-864', Guodong Zhang, 12 Nov 2026 reply
-
RC2: 'Comment on essd-2026-864', Anonymous Referee #2, 17 Nov 2026
reply
This manuscript presents a valuable and comprehensive set of forest data products for France by integrating remote sensing and national forest inventory data. The study provides detailed information on forest growth, age, and disturbance dynamics at fine spatial and species-specific scales. The datasets are well organized and have considerable potential for forest monitoring and carbon modeling. However, several methodological and uncertainty-related issues require further clarification and improvement, as detailed below.
- The authors use the 25th–75th percentile growth curves to represent uncertainty. However, these quantiles primarily reflect biomass variability rather than uncertainty in the fitted parameters. Moreover, when inverted to estimate forest age, the 25th-percentile biomass curve produces higher age estimates than the 75th-percentile curve, reversing their numerical ordering. The authors should clarify the statistical interpretation of these ranges and ensure that the lower and upper age bounds are correctly described in the text and released data documentation.
- The three quantile growth curves share the same shape parameters (b and c), which mathematically results in identical half-saturation ages (t50) across all quantiles. Consequently, the 25th–75th percentile range provides no spread for t50, although t50 itself may still have estimation uncertainty. The authors should justify this assumption and clarify its implications for the derived growth metrics.
- The authors exclude declining biomass observations beyond 90 years and retain growth curves with a minimum R2 threshold of 0.2. These choices may affect the fitted growth parameters, particularly the asymptotic biomass. The authors should briefly justify these thresholds and comment on their potential influence on the results.
- Rotation periods are estimated from the mean age of harvested trees. However, these records may include trees removed through thinning or selective logging rather than final stand harvest. The authors should clarify whether different harvesting practices were distinguished and justify the use of mean harvest age as a proxy for stand rotation period.
- The authors use separate one-way η2 analyses to compare the contributions of species categories and ecological regions. However, these factors are not independent, and their explained variances may overlap. Therefore, the conclusion that intrinsic species traits are more important than regional environmental conditions is not fully supported.
- The treatment of years without detected disturbances and the calculation of Sen's slopes require clarification. Excluding zero-disturbance years or ignoring irregular time intervals may bias the estimated disturbance rates and trends. The authors should verify these procedures, correct any resulting biases, and assess their potential impact on the reported results.
- The manuscript contains several formatting and reporting inconsistencies. For example, the variable names and units in Table 2 should be checked against the released datasets, and panels (k) and (l) are incorrectly referenced in the Figure 5 caption. The authors should also clarify the actual rotation-age correction applied, as the text specifies +2.5 years, whereas the example code configuration uses 3 years plus a species-specific correction. The authors should review the manuscript and data documentation for consistency and minor errors.
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/essd-2026-864-RC2
Data sets
Species- and region-specific growth curves, forest age, and disturbance trends for French forests at 30 m resolution (2020) Agnès Pellissier-Tanon et al. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23499335
Model code and software
essd_france_forest_code Agnès Pellissier-Tanon https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23503540
Viewed
| HTML | XML | Total | Supplement | BibTeX | EndNote | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 331 | 122 | 19 | 472 | 55 | 32 | 31 |
- HTML: 331
- PDF: 122
- XML: 19
- Total: 472
- Supplement: 55
- BibTeX: 32
- EndNote: 31
Viewed (geographical distribution)
| Country | # | Views | % |
|---|
| Total: | 0 |
| HTML: | 0 |
| PDF: | 0 |
| XML: | 0 |
- 1
This manuscript presents five linked datasets describing biomass growth, forest age, disturbance rates and severity, and harvest age across metropolitan France. The combination of 30 m age mapping with species- and region-specific summaries will be useful for forest carbon studies. The comparisons with National Forest Inventory data help readers interpret the products. A few points about the methods and data documentation would benefit from clarification. I recommend major revision.