Surface and bottom in situ, interpolated hydrographic climatologies of the Northwest Atlantic Ocean for 2000–2024
Abstract. New in situ, interpolated hydrographic monthly climatologies were created for the Northeast U.S. Continental Shelf (NES) and surrounding boundary waters for the years 2000–2024. The climatologies were created at two depth bins: the surface and bottom, where the surface is defined as observations averaged above the mixed layer depth, and the bottom includes all averaged data within 10 meters of the bathymetric bottom. The products described here rely solely on in situ measurements rather than satellite imagery, as satellite-derived products can be coarse and only reflect the skin layer of the ocean. Multiple point data sources and data collection methods, including observations collected from traditional vertical oceanographic profiles, flowthrough systems, buoys, gliders, and others, were aggregated to create the in situ dataset. Spatiotemporal Barnes objective analysis was performed to create the monthly climatologies for both temperature and salinity at the two depth bins. Root mean squared error (RMSE) and an uncertainty metric were provided with the interpolation. The uncertainty metric highlights regions and seasons that are data-poor and/or highly variable, and where there is lower confidence in the interpolated values. Results were validated using reference climatologies created using Global Ocean Reanalysis and Simulations (GLORYS) modeled data with the same spatiotemporal bounds. The surface temperature and salinity climatologies both yield significant correlations when compared to the reference climatologies (bias<|1.068| °C). Lower correlations in the winter months are observed during validation of bottom temperature climatologies, due to seasonal sampling bias. The products described here provide high-resolution, updated monthly climatologies derived from in situ data that may be used for anomaly detection or other modeling efforts. The climatologies can be accessed at doi:10.5281/zenodo.20183494 (Synan et al., 2026a) and the data used to create them can be accessed at doi:10.5281/zenodo.22696811 (Synan et al., 2026b).
Comments essd-2026-751
Surface and bottom in situ , interpolated hydrographic climatologies of the Northwest Atlantic Ocean for 2000-2024
Haley Synan et al.
General comment
The paper reports data that can be used to investigate the effects of climate and environmental changes. It focuses on the effects observed since the beginning of the 21st century in the northeastern part of the Atlantic Ocean. The paper is based on a considerable amount of data collection and assessment of their quality. The amount of data analyzed is truly remarkable, and therefore it is practically impossible to investigate in depth certain specific aspects related to data consistency, although a great deal of work has also been done in this regard. In addition to what the authors have done in paragraph 2, consistency could be analyzed using principal component analysis, which could lead to a ‘more objective’ subdivision of the data containing estuarine signals.
The paper is interesting as it stands and deserves to be published, but some clarifications are needed regarding certain parameters used in the formulas, as I will explain in the specific comments.
Specific comments
Line 161. River runoff is certainly important on continental shelves. I assume that the decision to exclude data relating to estuaries is dictated by its spatio-temporal variability. It would be useful to know at what distance from the coast the influence of river waters can be measured. The authors need to provide a more precise explanation of the choices made (why a 0.15° buffer).
Line 179. Details are missing regarding the choice of mixed layer depth. Figure 2 seems to indicate that it is defined at the end of the surface variability in the binned data. The choice could be made using full-resolution profiles, and the results could be different.
Para 2.8. Barnes Objective Interpolation requires parameters that may be somewhat subjective. For example, the convergence parameter was set to 0.2. The authors should provide more information on all the choices made.
Final comment
The article deserves to be published after these clarifications