the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
High-Resolution Wide-Coverage Urban Canopy Parameters for Urban Simulations in Weather Research and Forecasting Models
Abstract. Cross-disciplinary researchers focusing on connected urban processes, especially those running numerical weather simulations at microscales, require reliable data on building footprints, heights and locations. For example, quantifying the impact of the thermal radiative properties of buildings on urban heating during a heat wave benefits from representation of the 3-dimensional physical characteristics of buildings within the urban location studied. Additionally, understanding how and where urban pollution travels within a city depends on how the buildings from ground level to building tops distort the air flow throughout the city. Even knowledge about which buildings may be susceptible to flooding given the magnitude of a recent rainstorm can be clarified by knowing where buildings are located with respect to the elevation of the earth beneath and surrounding them. As urban micrometeorological modeling helps answer more local scientific questions, high resolution data with wide coverage are needed. Previous research into these issues has yielded useful products for simulating these effects at resolutions of 1 kilometer and coarser; however, no regional-weather-model-readable data products are available at block level resolution for the full extent of any city, county, or wider region. To address this gap, four data sets are presented here: 1) Chicago, 2) Washington, DC, 3) Los Angeles County, and 4) the Arizona “urban corridor.” Parameters include, at 100-meter resolution, frontal area density, plan area density, rooftop area density, plan area fraction, mean building height, standard deviation of building heights, area weighted mean of building heights, building surface area to plan area ratio, height to width ratio, sky view factor and roughness length calculations. These data sets were generated using a new Python tool and validated using statistical and visual methods.
- Preprint
(2032 KB) - Metadata XML
- BibTeX
- EndNote
Status: final response (author comments only)
- RC1: 'Comment on essd-2026-710', Anonymous Referee #1, 20 Sep 2026
-
RC2: 'Comment on essd-2026-710', Anonymous Referee #2, 24 Oct 2026
In the study titled, 'High-Resolution Wide-Coverage Urban Canopy Parameters for Urban Simulations in Weather Research and Forecasting Models', the authors present a new Python tool (NATURF) and four regional datasets of high-resolution (100m) urban canopy parameters across major U.S. domains. The study is well written and important for the urban climate and numerical weather modeling community. I have some concerns, especially about the unnecessarily broad framing, the fine-scale validation, and the large height differences observed in certain datasets.
Major comments:
- The introduction heavily frames the work as fulfilling a critical need for "block level resolution" and "neighborhood level" meteorological insights across cities, counties, and wider regions. However, the validation results show that the data only achieves reasonable statistical coherence when aggregated up to 200–400 meters. This creates a disconnect between the stated ambition of fine-scale neighborhood precision and the spatial scales at which the data actually exhibits statistical reliability. Given the low correlations at around 100 m, I would be very skeptical of the use of the dataset for running WRF at those resolutions. Moreover, ultimately the dataset is only provided for 4 cities while the title is overly generalized, calling it “wide-coverage” for instance. Many of the datasets required for the workflow cannot really be scaled globally or even regionally without substantial quality degradation. And a lot of typical WRF simulations are done for larger domains and over other cities, making the global 1 km products much more practical. As such, that this dataset is only being developed for these 4 cities at this point should be mentioned in the title and the generalization of the claims about the utility of this product needs to be tempered.
- There are large height differences between datasets that underscore the uncertainties in urban morphology inputs. For example, a direct comparison between Model America and Open DC for Washington, DC revealed a maximum absolute height difference of 60 meters, with over 155,000 buildings present in one dataset but missing entirely in the other. Similarly, cell-level comparisons show substantial scatter and bias across urban centers. This needs further discussion regarding what these discrepancies mean for the practical use of these varying datasets and the downstream uncertainties they would cause in WRF simulations.
- Building heights in the input dataset derived from digital surface models using convolutional methods and slope correction, with missing heights imputed using the median of the twenty closest buildings, can severely distort vertical profiles in mixed-height neighborhoods. Furthermore, comparing independent validation datasets from disparate years (e.g., Chicago data from 2023, Phoenix LiDAR from 2014, Los Angeles GIS from 2020) against a 2015 baseline model confounds model error with actual real-world urban growth or demolition. The authors should discuss or quantify how much of the reported error stems from these imputation artifacts and temporal mismatches versus the NATURF methodology itself.
- The main goal of developing this dataset is for use in weather models like WRF. However, while the authors mention the existence of other such morphological datasets, no comparison is done with, say, GloUCP, UT-GLOBUS, and U-Surf. Given that these other datasets are at 1 km (or easily aggregatable to a common grid), it should be easy enough to perform a benchmarking against them for the 4 regions. This comparison will also be useful to the broad urban climate community to better understand differences between and potential biases in commonly used products.
Minor comments:
- Line 65: Note that U-Surf has now been adapted for WRF (Jiang et al. 2026).
Reference:
- Jiang, T., Chakraborty, T., Cheng, Y., Mukherjee, R., Zhao, L., & Martilli, A. (2026). Impact of spatially continuous urban surface properties on summertime and heatwave simulations: A multi-city analysis. Journal of Advances in Modeling Earth Systems, 18, e2026MS005775. https://doi.org/10.1029/2026MS005775
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/essd-2026-710-RC2
Data sets
Urban Parameters for Chicago, Illinois, USA at 100m resolution Chris Vernon, Melissa Allen-Dumas, Pouya Vahmani https://doi.org/10.57931/2572297
Urban Parameters Washington, DC 100m Melissa Allen-Dumas, Chris Vernon, Pouya Vahmani https://doi.org/10.57931/2998536
Urban Parameters Los Angeles County 100m version 2 Levi Sweet-Breu, Melissa Allen-Dumas, Chris Vernon, Pouya Vahmani https://doi.org/10.57931/3000523
Urban Parameters Arizona Urban Corridor 100m Melissa Allen-Dumas, Chris Vernon, Pouya Vahmani https://doi.org/10.57931/2998499
Model code and software
Neighborhood Adaptive Tissues for Urban Resilience Futures (NATURF) Melissa R. Allen-Dumas, Levi Sweet-Breu, Emily Rexer, Chris Vernon https://github.com/IMMM-SFA/naturf/
Viewed
| HTML | XML | Total | BibTeX | EndNote | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 465 | 169 | 63 | 697 | 65 | 66 |
- HTML: 465
- PDF: 169
- XML: 63
- Total: 697
- BibTeX: 65
- EndNote: 66
Viewed (geographical distribution)
| Country | # | Views | % |
|---|
| Total: | 0 |
| HTML: | 0 |
| PDF: | 0 |
| XML: | 0 |
- 1
This manuscript presents urban canopy parameter (UCP) datasets at 100 m resolution for four urban regions in the United States to support urban simulations in the Weather Research and Forecasting model. These datasets could be useful for representing urban morphology in numerical models. However, several aspects require clarification, particularly the scope of validation. My specific comments are as follows.
1. The title should explicitly indicate that the datasets cover four urban regions in the United States. The current wording, particularly “Wide-Coverage,” could lead readers to expect a dataset with much broader or even global coverage. Specifying the geographical scope would better align the title with the contents of the manuscript.
2. Line 101: Imputation of missing building heights. The manuscript states that missing building heights were imputed using the median height of the twenty nearest buildings. Please justify the suitability of this approach and the choice of twenty neighbors. Building heights can vary considerably over short distances, and proximity alone may not adequately represent local morphological differences. Given the target resolution of 100 m, errors in imputed heights could affect the derived UCPs. Please report the proportion and spatial distribution of buildings with missing heights in each study region and evaluate the accuracy of the imputation method, for example by withholding known heights and comparing the estimates with the original values. The implications of imputation uncertainty for the resulting UCPs should also be assessed.
3. Please specify the reference year or acquisition period of the source data used to derive the UCPs for each study region. If building footprints and heights come from different years or sources, please explain how these temporal inconsistencies were handled and clarify the period that the resulting datasets represent.
4. The current validation focuses on mean building height, which is insufficient to establish the reliability of the full range of parameters provided. I recommend extending the evaluation through comparisons with existing UCP datasets for additional shared variables, such as plan area fraction, frontal area density, and building height variability, where available. Such comparisons should account for differences in spatial resolution, parameter definitions, and reference years. A broader quantitative evaluation would provide stronger support for the reliability of the datasets and help identify parameter-specific uncertainties.
5. Line 31: There appears to be an extra occurrence of “approaches.” Please remove the redundant word.
6. Line 87: The expression “at 15 5m intervals” is unclear and appears to contain a typographical or formatting error. Please correct it and clearly specify the intended interval.