the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
An equidistant nodal orthogonal polynomial fitting model for the central Pacific Ocean basin derived from satellite altimeter data: eight major tidal harmonic constants
Abstract. High-precision tidal harmonic constants serves as an important foundation for numerical ocean tidal modeling and studies of tidal dynamics. Prior studies have validated the applicability and efficacy of the equidistant node orthogonal polynomial for the fitting of tidal harmonic constants. In this study, observational records acquired from the TOPEX/Poseidon, Jason-1, Jason-2, and Jason-3 satellite altimetry missions are employed to conduct a systematic tidal harmonic analysis over the Central Pacific Basin. The dataset generated by the Equidistant Node Orthogonal Polynomial Fitting (ENOPF) model for the Central Pacific Basin (170° E–230° W, 30° S–30° N) was used to construct cotidal charts for the eight major tidal constituents (M₂, S₂, N₂, K₂, K₁, O₁, P₁, Q₁). The dataset has a spatial resolution of 3′ × 3′, and its tidal amplitude and phase lags are quantitatively compared with outputs from the Finite Element Solutions 2014 (FES2014), FES2022b, Empirical Ocean Tide 20 (EOT20), Tidal Prediction eXtended OSU 10 (TPXO10), and Technical University of Denmark 16 (DTU16) tide models. The results show that, relative to the comparative models, the vector error (VE), mean absolute error of amplitude (ΔH), and mean absolute error of phase lag (ΔG) computed with satellite altimeter data and tide gauges exhibit superior performance using ENOPF dataset. For example, for the M2, S2, K1, and O1 tidal constituents, the vector errors between the ENOPF-derived dataset and data from satellite altimeters were 0.91, 0.44, 0.41, and 0.21 cm. Furthermore, the ENOPF method offers a simpler and faster method for improving resolution; subsequently, by extracting the polynomial coefficients, a more detailed dataset with resolution of 1′ × 1′ can be constructed. This high-precision tidal harmonic constant dataset for the Central Pacific Basin offers significant application advantages, providing more reliable data support and technical references for tidal dynamics, ocean circulation, and marine engineering projects in the region.
- Preprint
(2808 KB) - Metadata XML
- BibTeX
- EndNote
Status: final response (author comments only)
-
RC1: 'Comment on essd-2026-233', Thomas Monahan, 02 Jul 2026
-
AC1: 'Reply on RC1', Xianqing Lv, 27 Jul 2026
We sincerely appreciate the reviewer for describing our work as interesting and potentially valuable. We are particularly grateful for the constructive feedback provided by the reviewer, and we have addressed their concerns point by point. Detailed responses are provided in the submitted file ‘essd-2026-233-AC1-supplement’. In this file, each comment has been addressed in detail, with the responses organised in the format ‘Question (black) – Response (blue) – Revision (red)’.
-
AC1: 'Reply on RC1', Xianqing Lv, 27 Jul 2026
-
RC2: 'Comment on essd-2026-233', Anonymous Referee #2, 10 Nov 2026
This manuscript presents a dataset of harmonic constants for eight major tidal constituents for the central Pacific basin, derived using the Equidistant Node Orthogonal Polynomial Fitting (ENOPF) method and satellite altimetry observations. Although the development of regional tidal datasets is potentially valuable, I have substantial concerns regarding the independence of the validation datasets and the reliability of the reported improvements.
Overall, this manuscript appears to be another regional application of the ENOPF method, similar to several previous publications by the authors. First, the manuscript does not present substantial methodological improvements to the ENOPF method. Second, the amount of satellite altimetry data used in this manuscript is much smaller than that used into current global tide models. Therefore, neither the method nor the observational data support the authors’ claims of improved accuracy.
Major Concerns
- The processing of the satellite altimetry data is not clearly described. Inter-mission biases exist among the four satellite missions (T/P, Jason-1, Jason-2, and Jason-3). Have these biases been accounted for? If so, how were they corrected?
- The description of the ENOPF method, its implementation procedures, and the cross validation lacks sufficient clarity. On one hand, it is unclear how the tidal harmonic constants derived from the processed satellite altimetry observations are used in the ENOPF method. On the other hand, can the manuscript provide uncertainty estimates for the ENOPF method?
- The satellite altimetry data used in the manuscript are limited to T/P, Jason-1, Jason-2, and Jason-3, which have relatively sparse ground-track coverage, with inter-orbit spacing reaching about 3°, as shown in Figure 2. Based on such sparse spatial observations, the reliability of the 3′ × 3′ or even 1′ × 1′ resolutions obtained with the ENOPF method is low. Therefore, the upper limit of the resulting resolution needs to be taken into account.
- From Figures 5 and 6, it can be seen that the result of the ENOPF method proposed in this manuscript is smoother than that of other models and contains less spatial details. This is also attributable to the limited input altimetry data and sparse ground tracks. Therefore, the fact that the accuracy of the ENOPF method is comparable to that of the other models can only indicate that the ocean tide variations in the region selected by the authors are very small and that the models agree well with one another, as shown in Table 5. scientific significance of the study is limited.
- When comparing models using satellite altimetry data, were the data used for the accuracy assessment involved in model construction, and how independent are they from the model construction? The results in Table 4 are better than those in Table 5, which further raises doubts about the independence of the altimetry data used for validation.
Minor Concerns
- Equation (2) should be revised to improve the clarity and completeness of the mathematical formulation. It does not include a residual term.
- Why is the GOT5.6 model not included among the models used for comparison? The GOT series is representative of empirical ocean tide models.
- Figure 4 shows that the error at tide gauge station 3 is relatively large, which may indicate a problem with the data at this station; verification is recommended.
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/essd-2026-233-RC2
Viewed
| HTML | XML | Total | BibTeX | EndNote | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 495 | 132 | 120 | 747 | 148 | 118 |
- HTML: 495
- PDF: 132
- XML: 120
- Total: 747
- BibTeX: 148
- EndNote: 118
Viewed (geographical distribution)
| Country | # | Views | % |
|---|
| Total: | 0 |
| HTML: | 0 |
| PDF: | 0 |
| XML: | 0 |
- 1
The authors demonstrate the application of a an equidistant nodal orthogonal polynomial fitting model for estimating tidal constituents from altimetry data with a focus on the Central Pacific. While I believe the author's approach to exploiting the spatial coherence of the oceanic response is interesting and potentially valuable, I have major concerns about their validation and conclusion as outlined below.
Major concern #1: It is not clear what altimeter data they are validating their fitted model on. It appears that it is the same data they used to train the model. In which case, the validation is not a fair comparison with the other models and their superior performance is entirely expected. I would encourage the authors to validate on independent altimetry data which has not been assimilated into any of the models they benchmark against or their model -- SWOT would be extremely useful for this. Without independent validation I don't feel these results tell us anything.
Major concern #2: Smooth co-tidal maps are not validation and in fact may point to a weakness of the approach. By definition, the authors polynomial fitting approach guarantees this result; however, this feature can lead to neglect of physical features of tidal variability. For example, all of the benchmark models show shifts in the co-tidal lines occurring around islands like Fiji which is entirely expected. By virtue of fitting coarse polynomial features the author's approach neglects this by definition. To me this is a clear weakness of the authors approach and counters the claim that their model can be downscaled to a higher effective resolution. Their claim of increasing the resolution of their approach either needs to be removed or substantiated.
Other miscellaneous comments:
-Tables need to have more informative labels. What does bold mean? Is there any notion of uncertainty? Can you compute whether changes are significant?
-Cross-validation: I would be interested to see the actual cross-validation results and not the final outcome. It is interesting that they all converge to orders 4 or 5.