Copernicus Publications and the Chief editors of ESSD thank the following colleagues very much for their work in reviewing the manuscripts published in the journal volume 15, 2023.
- Marc Adams
- Florian Adolphi
- Jeroen Aerts
- Jacopo Aguzzi
- Torsten Albrecht
- Douglas Alsdorf
- Ole Baltazar Andersen
- Leif Anderson
- David Antoine
- Shoji Arai
- Alexander Archibald
- Alexandre Badoux
- Oscar Manuel Baez Villanueva
- Wokil Bam
- Manjola Banja
- Qing Bao
- Sándor Baran
- Patrick Bartlein
- Mohamad Bazzi
- Francesca Bearzot
- Christina Belanger
- Marco Bellacicco
- Mar Benavides
- Wouter Berghuijs
- Leah Bertrand
- Jan Beutel
- Rakesh Bhambri
- Jian Bi
- Zihao Bian
- Jinhu Bian
- Roberta Bianchini
- Anne-Claire Billault–Roux
- Bruno Blanke
- Angela Bliss
- Xin Bo
- Olivier Bock
- Alejandro Bodas-Salcedo
- Donald Boesch
- emanuele bohm
- Marina Bolado-Penagos
- Tobias Bolch
- Dennis Booge
- Chris Boone
- René Booysen
- Emmanuel Boss
- Helen Bostock
- Oliver Bothe
- Mark Brenner
- Ellie Broadman
- Helene Brogniez
- Ian Brooks
- Fanny Brun
- Yanjiang Cai
- Elisa Calamita
- Jean-Christophe Calvet
- Andrés Camero
- Stefania Camici
- Bo Cao
- Mattias Cape
- Joana Cardoso-Fernandes
- Donna Carless
- David Carlson
- Brendan Carter
- Núria Casacuberta
- Mathieu Casado
- John Cassano
- Karel Castro-Morales
- Anny Cazenave
- silvia cerilli
- TC Chakraborty
- Jinfeng Chang
- Guillaume Charria
- Bin Chen
- Guangzhao Chen
- Hua Chen
- Sang Chen
- Jacopo Chiggiato
- Louise Chini
- Tiziana Ciuffardi
- Fabio Conte
- Laurent Coppola
- Luiz Carlos Cotovicz Junior
- Miguel Cruz
- Daniel Cusworth
- Raphaël d'Andrimont
- Junhu Dai
- Geoff Darch
- Niels de Winter
- Dick Dee
- Bridget Deemer
- Amaury Dehecq
- Daniel Marc dela Torre
- James Delaney
- Kyle Delwiche
- Hugo Denier van der Gon
- Anna Denvil-Sommer
- César Deschamps-Berger
- Mehmet Cengiz Deval
- Mathieu Dever
- Élise Devoie
- Graziella Devoli
- Timothy DeVries
- Christian DiMaria
- Minghu Ding
- Barnaby Dobson
- Albertus J. (Han) Dolman
- Alessio Domeneghetti
- Chunyu Dong
- Yuanxu Dong
- Zhenrong Du
- Gael Durand
- Emily Eidam
- Shane Elipot
- Jüri Elken
- Adam Emmer
- Louisa Emmons
- Ellyn Enderlin
- Jason Evans
- Peter Evans
- Daniel F. Nadeau
- Shah Wali Faryad
- Kuishuang Feng
- Settimio Ferlisi
- Cedric Fichot
- Christopher Fiebrich
- L. Fiorani
- Paolo Fiorucci
- Dirk Fleischer
- Lawrence Flynn
- Zeynab Foroozan
- Mike Foster
- Gillian Foulger
- Pierre Francus
- Katy Freeborough
- N.H.F. French
- Ralph Fyfe
- Samuel Gagnon
- Yongbao Gao
- Hernan Garcia
- Patrick Gatlin
- Y. Ge
- Tobias Gerken
- Emily Geyman
- Virendra Ghate
- H. Albert Gilg
- Colin Gleason
- Nicolaas Glock
- Danilo Godone
- Daniel L. Goldberg
- Yongmei Gong
- Ewa Grabska-Szwagrzyk
- Georgia Grant
- Jacopo Grazioli
- Vadim Grigoriev
- Jake Gristey
- Alexander Gruber
- Marc Guevara
- Gregoire Guillet
- Jinyun Guo
- Jianping Guo
- Tingting Guo
- Wolfgang Gurgiser
- Artyom Gusarov
- Robert Guza
- Sebastian Hahn
- Raed Halawi Ghosn
- David Hamilton
- Pengyu Hao
- Frank Hase
- István Gábor Hatvani
- Yi He
- Cenlin He
- wei he
- Junhao He
- Michael Heap
- Martin Heimann
- Maik Heistermann
- Robert Hellstrom
- Harrie-Jan Hendricks Franssen
- Sixto Herrera
- Thomas Hinton
- Christophe Hissler
- Maria Hoerhold
- Julian Hofer
- Christian Hogrefe
- Markus Hollaus
- Yuanqi Hong
- Xiaoming Hu
- Xinping Hu
- Tian Hu
- Chuanmin Hu
- Guanhua Huang
- Chang Huang
- Yan Huang
- Huilin Huang
- Jianxi Huang
- Xin Huang
- wenjuan Huang
- Romain Hugonnet
- Tom Hull
- Roberto Iacono
- Iolanda Ialongo
- Yosuke Iida
- Andrew Irwin
- Taka Ito
- Daniel Jacob
- Gergely Jakab
- Ehsan Jalilvand
- Greet Janssens-Maenhout
- Sungchan Jeong
- Bingrui Jia
- Aolin Jia
- chongya jiang
- Xin Jiang
- Shuanggen Jin
- Zhang Jingcheng
- Kerstin Jochumsen
- Sören Johansson
- Malin Johansson
- Andrew Johnson
- B. A. Johnson
- Nicholas Jones
- Matthew Jones
- Elizabeth Jones
- Lukas Jonkers
- Kyung Tae Jung
- Brian Kahn
- Johannes W. Kaiser
- Lars Kaleschke
- Yanghui Kang
- Shuh-Ji Kao
- Vasileios Karakostas
- A. Kasper-Giebl
- Anna Kato
- Jan Kavan
- Chang-Qing Ke
- Stefan Kern
- Hannah Kerner
- Rodrigo Kerr
- Elena Kharyutkina
- Daniel Kick
- Kwang-Il Kim
- Christoph Kittel
- Sofia E Kjellman
- Birgit Klein
- Marthe Klöcking
- Els Knaeps
- Tsubasa Kodaira
- Zoé Koenig
- Johnathan Kool
- Maartje Korver
- Ryan Kramer
- Arlin Krueger
- Inna Krylenko
- Wenhui Kuang
- Tracy Kugler
- Erico Kutchartt
- Guglielmo Lacorata
- Charles Lane
- Rosanna Lane
- Samantha Lavender
- Allison Lawman
- Matthew A. Lazzara
- Yoav Lehahn
- Polina Lemenkova
- Katharina Lengfeld
- Giulia Leone
- Stefano Letizia
- Husi Letu
- Xinghua Li
- Mengze Li
- Yue Li
- Xuecao Li
- Lingcheng Li
- Xiaoyong Li
- Yangfan Li
- Ruohan Li
- Fa Li
- Hui Li
- Xinyu Li
- Peirong Lin
- Shangrong Lin
- Piero Lionello
- Marina Lipizer
- Junjie Liu
- Zhizhao Liu
- Yang Liu
- Meng Liu
- Michael Lonardi
- Jenny Lovell
- Chaoqun Lu
- LEI MA
- Ziqiang Ma
- Han Ma
- Qin Ma
- Rosina Magaña Ugarte
- Federico Maggi
- Shamil Maksyutov
- Hanyang Man
- P. J. Mann
- Giuseppe M.R. Manzella
- Dehua Mao
- kebiao mao
- Marta Marcos
- Joao Martins
- Salvatore Marullo
- Florence Mazier
- David McJannet
- David McKee
- A. D. Mehr
- Outi Meinander
- Michael Melchin
- Lucas Menzel
- Benoit Meyssignac
- Konstantinos Michailos
- Mihai Micu
- John Miller
- Annalisa Minelli
- Peter Minnett
- Supriyo Mitra
- KOHEI MIZOBATA
- Ian Moffat
- Christophe Monnin
- Eric Morgan
- Stefan Mulitza
- Conor Murphy
- Mohsen Nabil
- Vishnu Nandan
- Andy Nelson
- Bruce Nelson
- Attila Nemes
- Brandi Newton
- Robbe Neyns
- Ionut Cristi Nicu
- Jens Nieschulze
- Tong Ning
- Masashi Niwano
- Simon Noone
- Ana Novo
- Stefan Noël
- Christopher O'Connor
- Tadayasu Ohigashi
- Jillian Ooi
- Sophie Opfergelt
- German Orizaola
- Claire Oswald
- Hans Paerl
- Laura Pan
- Zengxin Pan
- Xiaoping Pang
- Shinju Park
- Kanhu Charan Pattnayak
- Frank Paul
- Frank Pavia
- Hélène Peiro
- Livia Peiser
- Humberto Pereira
- Zoran Perić
- Lucia Perugini
- Glen Peters
- Ana Maria Roxana Petrescu
- Marc Pezerat
- Steven Phipps
- Paola Picco
- Sebastiano Piccolroaz
- David William Pierce
- Lucia Pineau-Guillou
- Jaime Pitarch
- Yadu Pokhrel
- Bernhard Pospichal
- Caroline Poulsen
- Evelyn Powell
- Malay Pramanik
- Michael Prather
- Jodie Pritchard
- Bram Prooijen, van
- Stephen Puetz
- Yuanwei Qin
- Shi Qiu
- Tristan Quaife
- Damien Raclot
- Elisa Ragno
- Riccardo Rainato
- Ekena Rangel Pinage
- Amila Sandaruwan Ratnayake
- Jens Redemann
- Vanessa Reinhart
- Hongrui Ren
- Zhengchao Ren
- Jasmin Renz
- Ekaterina Rets
- Alberto Ribotti
- Sigrid Roessner
- Martin Rogers
- Irina Rogozhina
- Enrique Rojas Villalba
- Michele Ronco
- M. Roughan
- Andrea Rovida
- Brandon Russell
- Peter Sadler
- Pablo Saide
- Alberto Sanchez
- Marta Sapena Moll
- Agustín Sarquis
- Farouk Sayed
- Giancarlo Scardia
- Gianvito Scaringi
- Paul Schattan
- Michael Scheuerer
- Joyce Schmatz
- Céline Schott
- Andrew Schwartz
- Tilo Schöne
- Federico Scoto
- Rocco Sedona
- Linda See
- Yuli Shan
- Wei Shangguan
- James Shanley
- Jonathan Sharp
- Julia A Shates
- Thomas Shaw
- Jonah Shaw
- Huizhong Shen
- Huanfeng Shen
- Miaogen Shen
- Youjiang Shen
- Wenjiao Shi
- Qinren Shi
- Hideo Shiogama
- Rajendra Shrestha
- Yanmin Shuai
- Peng Si
- Matthias Siewert
- Javier Sigro
- Israel Silber
- Simone Simeone
- Prafull Singh
- Christian Sippl
- Craig Smeaton
- William Smith
- David Smith
- Terry Sohl
- Monika Soja-Wozniak
- Christopher Somes
- Xiaopeng Song
- Javier Soto-Navarro
- Daan Speth
- Matthew Spydell
- Mathew Stiller-Reeve
- Gustav Strandberg
- Ulrich Strasser
- Alexander Strom
- Han Su
- Ning Sun
- Yu Sun
- Shanlei Sun
- Kristian Svennevig
- Brigitta Szabó
- Dan Mircea Tamas
- Ivy Tan
- Wenjun Tang
- Guoqiang Tang
- Ronglin Tang
- Toste Tanhua
- Chenliang Tao
- Susann Tegtmeier
- Ellen Thomas
- Rona Thompson
- James Thornton
- Hanqin Tian
- Hezhong Tian
- Jiaqi Tian
- Yasunori Tohjima
- Giovanni Toscani
- Khuong H. Tran
- Tim Trent
- Daiane Trevisan Ruwer
- Jens Turowski
- Johannes Uhl
- Gabor Ujvari
- Ignasi Vallès-Casanova
- Michiel van den Broeke
- Gerard van der Schrier
- Baptiste Vandecrux
- Melanie Vanderhoof
- Georg Veh
- Michael Vermeuel
- Benoit Veron
- Louise M. Vick
- Jean-Philippe Vidal
- Stefano Vignudelli
- Jeffrey Vincent
- Tuan Vu
- Haihong Wang
- Libo Wang
- Minyan Wang
- Q. Wang
- Aihui Wang
- Yi Wang
- Tao Wang
- Ou Wang
- Fei Wang
- Zhuonan Wang
- Lei Wang
- Scott Wankel
- Tomasz Wawrzyniak
- Tom Webb
- Ensheng Weng
- Jeremy Werdell
- Toby Westberry
- Leandra Weydt
- Jan Wienhöfer
- Jean-Pierre Wigneron
- James M. Wilczak
- Brent Wilder
- Robert Wilkes
- Daniel S. Wilks
- Malte Willmes
- Galina Wind
- Karina Winkler
- Eric Wolff
- Philip Woodworth
- Dianming Wu
- Penghai Wu
- Jan Marcin Węsławski
- Qiuxia Xie
- Jian Xu
- Yuyue xu
- Honghe Xu
- Donghui Xu
- Z. George Xue
- Xing Yan
- Yuzhen Yan
- Yikun Yang
- Yanzheng Yang
- Jiani Yang
- Yitong Yao
- Yuanzhi Yao
- Weiqi Yao
- Ana Maria Yañez-Serrano
- Takeo Yoshida
- Yongfa You
- Bofu Yu
- Zhen Yu
- Chenjie Yu
- Zhaowu Yu
- Qianqqiang Yuan
- Jiajia Yuan
- Chao Yue
- Yuemin Yue
- Elena Zakharova
- Luca Zappa
- Mark Zelinka
- Zhenzhong Zeng
- Yuan Zeng
- W. Zhan
- Xiaotong Zhang
- Yuzhong Zhang
- Yunjiang Zhang
- Shuliang Zhang
- Zhe Zhang
- Xiao Zhang
- Chen Zhang
- Miao Zhang
- Wei Zhang
- Hu Zhang
- Shuping Zhang
- Yu Zhao
- Chaoying Zhao
- Tianbao Zhao
- Tianjie Zhao
- Yanchen Zheng
- J. H. Zheng
- Shiyuan Zhong
- Yulong Zhong
- chuanlong zhou
- Guofeng Zhu