the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
A fjord dataset for multidisciplinary applications: Thirteen years of ocean observations in Sermilik Fjord, Southeast Greenland
Abstract. As global atmosphere and ocean temperatures rise and the Greenland Ice Sheet loses mass, the glacial fjords of Kalallit Nunaat/Greenland play an increasingly critical role in our climate system. Fjords are pathways for freshwater from ice melt to reach the ocean and for deep, warm, nutrient–rich ocean waters to reach marine–terminating glaciers, supporting abundant local ecosystems that Greenlanders rely upon. Research in Greenland fjords has become more interdisciplinary and more observations are being collected in fjords than in previous decades. However, there are few long–term (> 10 years) datasets available for single fjords. Additionally, observations in fjords in general are often spatially and temporally disjointed, utilize multiple observing tools, and are rarely provided in formats that are easily used across disciplines or audiences. We address this issue by providing standardized, gridded summer season hydrographic sections for Sermilik Fjord in Southeast Greenland, from 2009–2023. Gridded data facilitate the analysis of coherent spatial patterns across the fjord domain, and are a more accessible and intuitive data product compared to discrete profiles. We combined ship–based conductivity, temperature, and depth (CTD) profiles with helicopter–deployed eXpendable CTD (XCTD) profiles from the ice mélange region to create objectively mapped (or optimally interpolated) along–fjord sections of conservative temperature and absolute salinity. From the gridded data, we derived a summer season climatological mean and root mean square deviation, summarizing typical fjord conditions and highlighting regions of variability. This information can be used by model and laboratory studies, fjord intercomparison studies, biological and ecosystem studies in the fjord, and provides context for interpreting previous work. All original profile observations, gridded data, and climatological products are publicly available in netCDF format at Arctic Data Center and GitHub. The code used has also been made available to facilitate continued updates to the Sermilik Fjord gridded data product and applications to other fjord systems.
- Preprint
(9668 KB) - Metadata XML
-
Supplement
(2402 KB) - BibTeX
- EndNote
Status: open (until 13 Sep 2025)
-
RC1: 'Comment on essd-2025-345', Anonymous Referee #1, 25 Aug 2025
reply
Review of "A fjord dataset for multidisciplinary applications: Thirteen years of ocean observations in Sermilik Fjord, Southeast Greenland”
By Aurora Roth et al.
The paper is well written and should become a useful reference for future use of this data set. There is many years of dedicated effort to collect this important dataset, and the presented summer climatology is well organized. The figures are also clear and show many examples of how the observations have been synthesized to show variability. While many of the presented results were ‘as expected’ for a Southeast Greenland fjord, it is good that this is published and that the 2009 – 2023 observations make sense compared to earlier work. The suggested improvements are small and few enough to tick off the ‘minor’ revisions here.
General comment: The minor revisions needed are some unclear formulations and there were also a few errors around referencing figures. The one larger issue I have is that although an impressive number of summer campaigns is presented, it is still ‘summer only’. I strongly suggest that the data is described as summer data. In line 270 for example, you state; “all profiles collected in the fjord across all years”. This makes it sound like you have representative data for “all years” - - you don’t. You have good representation for summers. This should be corrected throughout.
Specific comments:
Line 78,79,80: This text is repeated and should be deleted. It is also unclear what 'annual gridded dataset' is compared to the summertime means.
Lilne 100: Here you need to add “SA”; Absolute Salinity (SA) 33.3 g kg-1.
Line 157: Missing figure reference; “except for 2014 and 2020 (??).”
Line 159: I don’t know what you try to indicate with the (1)… Please fix.
Line 161: Wrong format for the deg C.
Line 179: Probably the Greenlandic name for Midgaard Fjord is missing?
Line 180: I don’t know what you try to indicate with the (2)… Please fix.
Line 181: Wrong format for the deg C.
Line 220: I don’t know what you try to indicate with the (3)… Please fix.
Line 270 I suggest to just write; “all profiles collected in the fjord across all summers”
Line 346: And here then “each summer” instead of “each year”.
Line 350: Again here you write “all the yearly data”. I think that you did not include the March XCTD profiles? In any regard – please specify if this is summer data (July – September).
Caption Figure 4: “The 2023 CTD and XCTD data are not combined and instead treated as two separate instances of a summer fjord state leading to a total of 14 possible grids.” This is clearly written also in the text, you only need to explain this once. I suggest to delete this here.
Line 392: Here you use the correct term. You have produced “a summer state climatology”.
Line 393: Missing figure refence.
Line 418: I think you are missing something here; “The subsurface temperature minimum of this profile indicates the core of the PW layer present on the shelf.” Surely – this must be the remnant of the lower part of the PW from the previous winter situation? Please clarify.
Figure 9 caption has missing Figure (??) reference.
Line 449: The stratification (density) is not visible in Fig. 10. Do you mean thermocline??
Line 463: Missing figure refence (??).
Line 475: Figure 8 c) shows the mean salinity – not the variability. And the variability in the mouth region is only large for Temperature. Please rephrase.
Line 528: Here there is a very welcome comment on the large seasonal variability in freshwater forcing. I think you should also mention the large (trivial) solar seasonal variability that drives it. This must explain the maximum surface variability for temperature shown in Figure 8 b).
Otherwise it was a nice paper. The data collection is impressive and the new climatology will be very useful.
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/essd-2025-345-RC1
Data sets
Gridded hydrographic dataset for Sermilik Fjord, Southeast Greenland from 2009 - 2023 Aurora Roth, Fiamma Straneo, James Holte, Margaret Lindeman https://doi.org/10.18739/A2513TZ0P
Sermilik Fjord Hydrography Data Portal Aurora Roth, Fiamma Straneo, James Holte, Margaret Lindeman https://arcticdata.io/catalog/portals/sermilik/Data
Model code and software
sermilik_gridded_hydrography Aurora Roth https://github.com/a1roth/sermilik_gridded_hydrography
Viewed
HTML | XML | Total | Supplement | BibTeX | EndNote | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
197 | 42 | 11 | 250 | 10 | 13 | 12 |
- HTML: 197
- PDF: 42
- XML: 11
- Total: 250
- Supplement: 10
- BibTeX: 13
- EndNote: 12
Viewed (geographical distribution)
Country | # | Views | % |
---|
Total: | 0 |
HTML: | 0 |
PDF: | 0 |
XML: | 0 |
- 1