the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
The COASTℓOOC project dataset
Philippe Massicotte
Marcel Babin
Frank Fell
Vincent Fournier-Sicre
David Doxaran
Abstract. Coastal Surveillance Through Observation of Ocean Color (COASTℓOOC) oceanographic expeditions were conducted in 1997 and 1998 to examine the relationship between the optical properties of seawater and related biological and chemical properties across the coastal-to-open ocean gradient along the European coasts. A total of 379 stations were visited along the coasts of the Gulf of Lion in the Mediterranean Sea (n = 61), Adriatic Sea (n = 39), Baltic Sea (n = 57), North Sea (n = 99), English Channel (n = 85) and Atlantic Ocean (n = 38). A particular emphasis has been dedicated to the collection of a comprehensive set of apparent (AOPs) and inherent (IOPs) optical properties to support the development of ocean color remote sensing algorithms. The data were collected in situ using traditional ship-based sampling, but also from a helicopter, which is a very efficient means for that type of coastal sampling. The dataset collected during the COASTℓOOC campaigns is still today quite unique in that it is fully consistent in terms of operators, protocols, and instrumentation. This rich and historical dataset is still today frequently requested and used by other researchers. Therefore, we present the result of an effort to compile and standardize a dataset which will facilitate their reuse in future development and evaluation of new bio-optical models adapted for optically-complex waters. The dataset is available at https://doi.org/10.17882/93570 (Massicotte et al., 2023).
Philippe Massicotte et al.
Status: final response (author comments only)
-
CC1: 'Comment on essd-2023-83', ZhongPing Lee, 14 Apr 2023
This manuscript describes the well known and widely used dataset collected by the COASTLOOC project. It is in general well described, but further polish is necessary. Specifically,
- A few citations not available, such as line 30, “Sat, 2000”.
- Font size of many figures (e.g., Fig. 2) should be larger.
- Incomplete sentences (e.g., line 54, “… boat (some samples were collected in waters 55 as shallow as 1 m, Babin 2003”).
- Line 119, R(0+), a typo. Also, please check the grammar of this sentence and the entire manuscript.
- Line 121, “using a sum of two exponential functions to account for Raman scattering”. Need more information on why “two exponential functions”. On the other hand, from the figures in A1, it appears after ~1 m, the Eu(779) is no longer valid.
- Further, for Eu data, did you carry out correction of instrument self shading?
- The increase of Eu(683,706) with depth showing in Fig. 3 suggests this measurement is quite questionable.
- Suggest to include a section to specifically to talk about uncertainties associated with the measured parameters.
- Fig. 7, for Y axis, suggest to use dynamic range, so the R spectra can be presented more clearly.
Citation: https://doi.org/10.5194/essd-2023-83-CC1 -
RC1: 'Comment on essd-2023-83', Emmanuel Boss, 28 Apr 2023
This paper is very important as it provides an introduction to a unique dataset to the community in its full glory. I strongly support publishing it. However I think the text can be significantly improved. In particular mentioning figures in sentences should be avoided and rather they should be cited in brackets while the text includes only what we learn from the data in those figures. Also, some figure captions (Fig. 3) include description of data characteristics that are never mentioned in the text. There are some 'Frenchisms' that could be made clearer (I made suggestions in the attached annotated PDF. Finally, the conclusion section does not do justice to the importance of the data set and the impact it had and likely will have in the future on the field of ocean optics in general and ocean color remote sensing in particular.
All the best, Emmanuel Boss, UMaine
-
RC2: 'Comment on essd-2023-83', David McKee, 02 May 2023
The Coastlooc project was a trailblazer for the marine optics community, providing an unusually rich and complete data set which remains relatively rare to this date. THe list of publictions that have previously used the data set is testament to its importance and this submission of a fully quality controlled version is a welcome step to ensure that it is available to the community for the future. I am certain that it will continue to be very highly valued and exploited as a result.
The authors have done a good job of describing the data set and I only have relatively minor comments in the attached marked up version. I would highlight the request to include uncorrected AC9 data so that users may select their own scattering correction.
Great job and delighted to see this data set being made available to the community.
-
RC3: 'Comment on essd-2023-83', Jenny Lovell, 08 May 2023
General Comments
The COASTlOOC project dataset is a comprehensive and useful collection and clearly has been widely used. To standardize the QC, version control and documentation is an important task and serves to improve the standing and usability of the dataset. This paper has sufficient detail to describe the data and collection methods, and directs the reader to original sources for more detailed information. The paper includes useful plots for a user to decide whether the data is suitable for them as well as the full description of variables in Table 1.Specific Comments
I would suggest that a text version of Table 1 would be useful to include with the dataset as a self-descriptor.I followed the link in the paper and was able to access the data archive successfully. The default file-names of the downloaded files are not useful and would be better if they were descriptive and with some indication of version (in case of any future updates or errata).
The quality of the figures is generally good, but font sizes are too small.
Technical Comments
Additional detailed comments are annotated in the attached file.
Philippe Massicotte et al.
Data sets
The COASTLOOC project dataset Philippe Massicotte, Marcel Babin, Frank Fell, Vincent Fournier-Sicre, and David Doxaran https://doi.org/10.17882/93570
Model code and software
The COASTLOOC project dataset Philippe Massicotte https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.7708653
Philippe Massicotte et al.
Viewed
HTML | XML | Total | BibTeX | EndNote | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
308 | 54 | 12 | 374 | 2 | 4 |
- HTML: 308
- PDF: 54
- XML: 12
- Total: 374
- BibTeX: 2
- EndNote: 4
Viewed (geographical distribution)
Country | # | Views | % |
---|
Total: | 0 |
HTML: | 0 |
PDF: | 0 |
XML: | 0 |
- 1